There is, however, a difference between the rule on
real-party-in-interest and the rule on standing, for the former is a
concept of civil procedure73 while the latter has constitutional underpinnings.74 In view of the arguments set forth regarding standing, it behooves the Court to reiterate the ruling in Kilosbayan, Inc. v. Morato75 to clarify what is meant by locus standi and to distinguish it from real party-in-interest.
The difference between the rule on standing and real
party in interest has been noted by authorities thus: "It is important
to note . . . that standing because of its constitutional and public
policy underpinnings, is very different from questions relating to
whether a particular plaintiff is the real party in interest or has
capacity to sue. Although all three requirements are directed towards
ensuring that only certain parties can maintain an action, standing
restrictions require a partial consideration of the merits, as well as
broader policy concerns relating to the proper role of the judiciary in
certain areas.
Standing is a special concern in constitutional law
because in some cases suits are brought not by parties who have been
personally injured by the operation of a law or by official action
taken, but by concerned citizens, taxpayers or voters who actually sue
in the public interest. Hence the question in standing is whether such
parties have "alleged such a personal stake in the outcome of the
controversy as to assure that concrete adverseness which sharpens the
presentation of issues upon which the court so largely depends for
illumination of difficult constitutional questions."
x x x
On the other hand, the question as to "real party in
interest" is whether he is "the party who would be benefited or injured
by the judgment, or the 'party entitled to the avails of the suit.'
4 comments:
nike air max 2017
yeezy boost 350
nike epic react
yeezy boost 350
kd 11 shoes
curry 6 shoes
kyrie shoes
golden goose
nba jerseys
air max 97
balenciaga shoes
golden goose outlet
spongebob kyrie 5
supreme shirt
golden goose
goyard
bape clothing
supreme clothing
supreme outlet
balenciaga trainers
g3p56j7l05 o7h69a4p86 l3n05o8o82 p8z01s8f04 q4v87f6w90 r2i07t3v48
kd shoes
hermes outlet
giannis shoes
golden goose
golden goose outlet
hermes bag
fear of god
hermes outlet online
jordan sneakers
fear of god clothing
Post a Comment